Vint Cerf on why TCP/IP was never patented

(seremot.com)

153 points | by emot 20 hours ago

13 comments

  • hn_submit 14 hours ago
    What interests me even more is that TCP/IP was never "finished." Cerf and others still had a to-do list they were working on when the DoD halted development and froze TCP/IP.

    What was this list of to-do items (I've seen it listed once) and what if they had finished it? What would the world look like then?

    • p_l 13 hours ago
      32bit addressing was supposed to be temporary stopgap with v4 being retired by 1990, for example
      • nticompass 5 hours ago
        Nothing is more permanent than a temporary solution.
        • LeFantome 4 hours ago
          I read the other day that the 8086 and its ISA was a “temporary solution”. 50 years and counting on that one too.
    • ilkkao 10 hours ago
      TCP and IP both have extension support (options). New options are still being standardized. Latest TCP option is RFC9768, added this year.
    • sybercecurity 4 hours ago
      That's the joke, it's never finished. The Internet is basically an instance of building a plane in flight that succeeded.
      • hn_submit 1 hour ago
        No, there was a finite list of things they were working on after which they considered it finished.
    • 1718627440 11 hours ago
      Is there software that is ever finished and doesn't have a todo list?
      • mhh__ 8 hours ago
        Quant finance is interesting because often your pricer for a given product will be useless until it's done and then never touched again whereas most software is useful from the beginning but never finished.
        • amomchilov 8 hours ago
          Are there ever new “insights” that would lead to an update?
          • mhh__ 3 hours ago
            Yes, typically a different class of models either from some new burst of creativity or computational tractability.
          • eugenekay 5 hours ago
            That becomes a new Product, sold at a higher rate to Favored clients.
      • prmoustache 10 hours ago
        There used to be many of them when internet wasn't widely available outside of universities and customers didn't expect to be beta testers.
      • knome 4 hours ago
        Software, like art, is never finished. Only abandoned.
  • crazybonkersai 11 hours ago
    A cool thing about Vint Cerf is that he looks like The architect from The Matrix series. I wonder if the cast was intentional or it is just a coincidence
    • zuluonezero 46 minutes ago
      The Cool thing about Vint Cerf is that he was a rocket scientist who co-invented the addressing system of the internet.
    • justin66 6 hours ago
      The Wachowskis have never confirmed this publicly that I'm aware of. On the other hand, yeah, it makes a lot of sense...
    • pak9rabid 4 hours ago
      Holy jeez, you're right!
    • gbxyz 9 hours ago
      It was intentional.
  • zoobab 13 hours ago
    Remember that computer programs are not patentable, in the US under SCOTUS jurisprudence Alice, and in the EU under EPC art52.2.

    Nevertheless, the Unified Patent Court just ignored the exclusion for a smartwatch, saying having a button bypasses the exception.

    • cowlevel 11 hours ago
      I believe the phrase "computer programs are not patentable" betrays a complete misunderstanding of patents, it is like saying that numbers are not copyrightable.
    • dv_dt 11 hours ago
      Software hardware combinations have always been patentable even if software alone only has copyright protection
    • freejazz 7 hours ago
      That's not what Alice stands for at all
    • kube-system 5 hours ago
      True, you only have to worry about patents if you want to do things like... actually use software on a computer, or provide it to others to use on a computer.
  • chuckadams 6 hours ago
    > At the launch, he and the network’s director smashed a plastic bottle of glitter over a Cisco router.

    Yikes. I think I'd rather see water splashed on a machine instead of glitter: that stuff gets everywhere, shorts things out, and unlike water, never seems to go away.

  • meialabscom 20 hours ago
    I feel like this sort of long term thinking is not likley to happen now. Are we too focused on monetization now? I feel this is mostly the influence of VC's in "innovation".
    • robmusial 19 hours ago
      Signal Protocol, RISC-V, WireGuard just off the top of my head are pretty major recent innovations that aren't patent encumbered. There are plenty of people doing interesting work not influenced by VC money.
      • hn_submit 13 hours ago
        My favorite non-patented CS invention of all time is...(drum roll) UTF-8!!

        Most people don't appreciate the amount of DRAM and disk memory saved by this brilliant invention. In the 90's Unicode (16-bit) was all the rage. But it required double the amount of storage for text which was mostly ASCII.

        The inventors should receive a Turing award (if they haven't already).

        • coldpie 6 hours ago
          When I first learned how UTF-8 encoding works (to fix a text rendering bug in Wine) I was blown away. It's such a beautiful and simple encoding and it manages to be backwards-compatible with the most important encoding that existed before it. What an accomplishment.
        • nine_k 13 hours ago
          The design of UTF-8 is by Ken Thompson and Rob Pike; the former actually has received the Turing Award (for other work).
      • kstenerud 15 hours ago
        JSON, HTTP, Markdown, CSV, HTML, almost every programming language, SSH, AV1, ODF, Open protocol, Linux, POSIX, OpenGL, Wayland, Vulkan, Opus, SeaBIOS, GCC, LLVM, LXC, USB...
      • euroderf 12 hours ago
        Is USB-C patent-encumbered ? It finally rid the world of serial and parallel ports. A local maximum of nirvana.
        • cowlevel 11 hours ago
          I'm not sure but don't forget it's illegal because trademarks to say your product has a USB port, unless you're a paying member of the USB-IF and it's been compatibility tested.
      • hn_submit 13 hours ago
        Protocols are a dime a dozen. Every competent developer could make one up just by mixing and matching things.

        And RISC-V was originally an educational ISA which got out of hand and found traction in the commercial sector. Primarily because China feared getting locked-out of American and European ISAs.

        • throawayonthe 12 hours ago
          at least for the signal protocol it doesn't really apply, not at all something 'every' competent developer could make by mixing and matching things.
          • hn_submit 7 hours ago
            And why's that? I could easily come up with a comparable encryption protocol just by using different ciphers, hashes etc.

            China and Japan came up with their own digital TV standards by simply mixing up the order of the fields in the structs of the ATSC standard and possibly using slightly different compression methods.

            • keeda 4 hours ago
              I would say the difference is in the high-level structure of the protocol and the guarantees it provides. You’re right that once the structure is established the components could be fungible, but depending on what guarantees are being promised, coming up with the structure can be very non-trivial.

              Like, in security there are a zillion ways your protocol could be compromised even if there are no bugs in the code. I’m not familiar with the Signal protocol at all, but I do know the combination of guarantees it provides were unmatched until it came along.

              On the flip side “protocol” is a broad term, encompassing even a basic file format or a message between a client and server (hence “protobufs”!) where the only guarantee is “you will find this data at this location.” Those indeed are a dime a dozen, but they’re on the simpler end of the spectrum.

              • hn_submit 3 hours ago
                There's nothing special about the Signal protocol, except (maybe) the Double Ratchet mechanism which is merely a way to generate ephemeral message keys using hash functions.
      • lioeters 17 hours ago
        I read that if we didn't have public libraries and someone suggested the concept these days, it would never be built because it sounds like a socialist scheme. "Free access to books and self-education! Who does that profit?" Everyone, of course, society benefits.

        But there are good examples of technology for public benefit, and the more I pay attention, I see people are making efforts in various spaces, not just in technology but a variety of social activism on collective and personal level.

        The Internet, the web, and personal computers were miraculous for that historical period, it liberated the creative energy of following generations. The accelerating enshittification of our present time has managed to capture a lot of that value and cultural relevance, but the cutting edge has moved on elsewhere to find fresh expression.

        That is to say, I believe there is hope as long as people continue to engage with meaningful projects creating value for the commons, and even the toxic atmosphere of global exploitation may turn out to be the wake-up call and challenge for humanity to manifest social changes, including socially beneficial technological innovations, for a better future.

        • frankling_ 15 hours ago
          [...] but the cutting edge has moved on elsewhere to find fresh expression.

          Any pointers? Been looking for these elsewheres.

          • cowlevel 11 hours ago
            The pointers are necessarily not available in public, or they'd become enshittified the same way.
        • xhkkffbf 5 hours ago
          Free access? Libraries aren't free. You pay taxes for them. Also, libraries don't pirate. They pay for their books.
        • morcatabiew 15 hours ago
          Wikipedia, archive, ocw
        • miki123211 15 hours ago
          If libraries were invented in the 21st century, it would have been by a Silicon Valley entrepreneur "disrupting the copyright monopollies" with the innovative practice of "book sharing". They would quickly be criticized by authors and journalists alike and banned by some local governments.

          Libraries that required their members to pay fees did in fact exist historically. It's how many libraries in the US got started. They were private enterprises meant to make money (or at least be self-sustaining non-profits relying on a mix of donations and fees), not government-run projects.

          Libraries are an obvious workaround for the western copyright system[1]. Because this system lets us share existing book copies without the permission of the author, but doesn't allow us to print new ones for free even when the capability exists, the obvious way to make books cheaper is to serially share them across many readers and have each pay the fraction of the price. This is essentially what these libraries did, with fees as a stand-in for the price sharing that simplified their operation.

          [1] Yes, I'm aware that copyright isn't exactly necessary for libraries to exist; high printing costs would do it too. I do think that they would be entirely unnecessary and almost extinct (in well-functioning 21st-century democracies) if not for copyright, given our printing costs.

        • nine_k 13 hours ago
          > sounds like a socialist scheme

          Public libraries were invented in 1830s, and a few existed (notably Boston's), but the proliferation of tax-supported public libraries is entirely a capitalist scheme, implemented privately by Andrew Carnegie, a steelmaking magnate.

          • brookst 6 hours ago
            That’s not really how it works… something isn’t a capitalist policy because a capitalist person supported it.

            Fire departments are 100% socialist. That does not change depending on who supports or opposes them.

            Carnegie was an interesting character. Certainly a capitalist as a person, but his support of tax-funded libraries does not transform public libraries into capitalist institutions.

          • ninjalanternshk 10 hours ago
            The most capitalist thing about capitalism is that capitalists will do anti-capitalist things if it benefits them.
    • wmf 17 hours ago
      I think people appreciate the power of free and open standards much more now than in previous decades. Companies have shifted to more subtle forms of monetization than just making everything proprietary.
      • miki123211 15 hours ago
        Open standards have much better network effects, and so they're generally favored by the market.

        Companies would prefer for their standards to be proprietary, but open standards products often do better than proprietary ones, because of said network effects.

        This is not always true; sometimes the open standard and the required interoperability hampers innovation, hence why most enterprised moved off of standards-based Cisco products to Slack and Zoom.

    • abofh 16 hours ago
      Well, exactly. His boss wasn't measuring him by patents
    • jbmchuck 17 hours ago
      Yup. Now it would be called a moat.
    • ares623 15 hours ago
      Yes. The "open web" would be considered an abject failure of maximizing revenue and shareholder value.
  • Ey7NFZ3P0nzAe 18 hours ago
    Reminds me of:

    > - Who owns the patent on this vaccine?

    > - Jonas Salk: Well, the people, I would say. There is no patent. Could you patent the sun?

    - Jonas Edward Salk (October 28 1914 – June 23 1995) was a medical researcher and author, the inventor of the Salk vaccine against Polio

    • crossroadsguy 15 hours ago
      > Could you patent the sun?

      I, maybe a decade younger, would have said "never", "that's silly". Now? I am not sure. Hear me out. Imagine a scenario where someone had patented "harnessing energy from the sun using semiconductors and electrical circuits" and then can enforce that to a large part of the world. I mean what depresses me that it doesn't infeasible to me at all. Least of it will be the patent grant.

      • kps 6 hours ago
        They did. US 2780765 Solar energy converting apparatus (1954).
      • nine_k 13 hours ago
        Novelty would be hard to demonstrate. The amount of prior art has a literally galactic scale.
        • skinfaxi 7 hours ago
          If the prior art is nature it's still patentable no? Like if you designed a helicopter that flew like a dragonfly?
      • brookst 6 hours ago
        There are many patents on solar panel tech. That is not patenting the sun, any more than some EV motor patent is “patenting roads”.
    • saghm 18 hours ago
      Also worth remembering that the Eisenhower administration tried to resist giving the vaccine out for free because it was "socialized medicine".
      • nine_k 12 hours ago
        Giving valuable stuff out for free is often unwise. It won't be valued and hence wasted and squandered. It would be hoarded and resold if seen as valuable, e.g. if the supply is limited.

        There should be a cost, but it does not have to be monetary. A bureaucratic cost often works well enough: you don't pay for the stuff but you give identity in exchange, and are tracked to limit repeat orders. Or you can buy any amount of the stuff at the market price, but without all that.

        • saghm 7 hours ago
          > A bureaucratic cost often works well enough: you don't pay for the stuff but you give identity in exchange, and are tracked to limit repeat orders.

          You're describing literally exactly how vaccines are distributed, surrounded by a lot of apologism for the arguments against the exact thing you described.

        • euroderf 12 hours ago
          Email awaits some such solution.
          • cowlevel 11 hours ago
            It's called - and Hotmail had this in the 90s - exclusive spam filter. Any email from anyone not on your contact list is deleted.
      • nobody9999 12 hours ago
        >Also worth remembering that the Eisenhower administration tried to resist giving the vaccine out for free because it was "socialized medicine".

        Like most things, the story is more complicated and nuanced[0][1][2] than that.

        [0] https://www.asbmb.org/asbmb-today/science/092620/lessons-fro...

        [1] https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/full_html/2026/11/aa61214-...

        [2] https://flaglerlive.com/eisenhower-polio/

        • saghm 7 hours ago
          From your first source:

          > President Dwight D. Eisenhower expressed his belief that every child should receive the polio vaccine, without indicating how that would happen. Eisenhower charged Health, Education and Welfare Secretary Ovetta Culp Hobby to work out the details in coordination with Surgeon General Leonard Scheele.

          > Congressional Democrats advocated for a plan that would make the polio vaccine free to everyone, which Hobby rejected as a “back door to socialized medicine.”

          Yes, there are a lot of other details in the history of the polio vaccine, but I fail to see for this isn't exactly what I described. The person in Eisenhower's cabinet who he put in charge of figuring this out used those words in the context I described. The fact that it was preceded by "back door to" is only as "complicated and nuanced" as the understanding that a back door still leads to the same house as the front door.

          • nobody9999 6 hours ago
            >Yes, there are a lot of other details in the history of the polio vaccine, but I fail to see for this isn't exactly what I described. The person in Eisenhower's cabinet who he put in charge of figuring this out used those words in the context I described. The fact that it was preceded by "back door to" is only as "complicated and nuanced" as the understanding that a back door still leads to the same house as the front door.

            You're leaving out the part where Eisenhower requested USD$28,000,000 from Congress to purchase vaccine for free distribution to American children (from Eisenhower's 1955 "Statement to the Nation")[0]:

               To assist the States in providing free vaccinations, I have recommended that 
               the Congress enact legislation making $28 million available to the States for 
               the purchase of vaccine. This legislation is now being considered by the 
               appropriate Committees of the Congress and I urge its immediate adoption.
            
            Congress responded by passing a bill funding his request to the tune of USD$30,000,000. Eisenhower then signed that bill into law[1]:

               Eisenhower then signed the Polio Vaccination Assistance Act of 1955, which 
               slated $30 million to pay for vaccines – enough to fund wider public 
               distribution. Within a year, 30 million American kids had been inoculated, 
               and the number of polio cases had fallen almost by half.
            
            So yes, the Eisenhower Administration did push back. And then, for a variety of reasons, changed course and supported Federal funding of vaccines. Which is, as I said, more complex and nuanced than '...the Eisenhower administration tried to resist giving the vaccine out for free because it was "socialized medicine".'

            That's one part of the story. Why do you insist on ignoring the other parts of that same story?

            [0] https://flaglerlive.com/eisenhower-polio/

            [1] https://www.asbmb.org/asbmb-today/science/092620/lessons-fro... [N.B. this is the link you quoted from. Perhaps you should have read a few more paragraphs?]

            • saghm 3 hours ago
              I didn't said "insisted on not providing the vaccine for free". I said "tried to resist", which implies that they acquiesced. Why do you insist that this is not an accurate picture?
              • nobody9999 3 hours ago
                >I didn't said "insisted on not providing the vaccine for free". I said "tried to resist", which implies that they acquiesced.

                I never suggested anything like that. I asserted that your initial claim was over simplified, not that it was incorrect. More complex and nuanced means that there's more to the story, not that what you said was untrue.

                It absolutely was part of the truth. The rest of the story, which you declined to include or acknowledge, made your assertion incomplete rather than incorrect.

                You'll note that I said:

                   So yes, the Eisenhower Administration did push back. And then, for a variety 
                   of reasons, changed course and supported Federal funding of vaccines. Which 
                   is, as I said, more complex and nuanced than '...the Eisenhower 
                   administration tried to resist giving the vaccine out for free because it was 
                   "socialized medicine".'
                
                Where did I say your statement was inaccurate? I strongly implied that it wasn't the whole story (when I said that "Like most things, the story is more complicated and nuanced[0][1][2] than that.")

                I most certainly did not say your statement was wrong. I asserted that it was incomplete. See the difference?

                And when you quoted a section from one of the links I shared that supported your initial, incomplete assertion, I agreed with you and then filled out other parts of the story (some of which were included in the link you quoted) that your initial statement and further writing did not address.

                That's one part of the story. Why do you insist on ignoring the other parts of that same story? Nowhere did I claim that your initial statement was untrue. It absolutely is true. But it's just one part (and IMNSHO, not an important part, given the outcome) of the story of the US Government's (both the Executive and Legislative branches) response and support for distribution of the Polio vaccine.

                >Why do you insist that this is not an accurate picture?

                I didn't insist on anything of the kind. I said:

                   That's one part of the story. Why do you insist on 
                   ignoring the other parts of that same story?
                
                Which asserts that you are focusing only on a single part of the story and ignoring the rest of the story.

                We appear to be in violent agreement here. If I haven't made myself clear, then it's unlikely I will. In which case, my apologies for not being able to communicate more effectively.

      • rexpop 15 hours ago
        Yes, senator Barry Goldwater likewise characterized a government vaccination program as “socialized medicine by the back door, not the front door.”

        Goldwater would later to on to commit such atrocities as voting against the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and floating the use of atomic weapons in Vietnam.

  • keeda 4 hours ago
    Hah, I never realized Cerf was a homonym for “surf!” Nominative determinism or an eponymic Easter Egg?
  • JSR_FDED 15 hours ago
    I was in a meeting with Vint Cerf 20+ years ago. He’s an engineer’s engineer and you immediately pick up on the combination of intelligence, focus, discipline and an ability to zoom out and see the bigger picture. Very impressive. He’s also humble and very approachable - and dresses better than you :-)
    • jibalt 15 hours ago
      When I worked for the UCLA CompSci dept in 1969 I dressed like a hippie (as did Jon Postel and many others), but Vint always wore a 3-piece suit and carried a briefcase. (His bud Steve Crocker was more a pocket protector engineer type.)
  • emot 20 hours ago
    full transcript here: ourfuturestories.eu/vint-cerf
    • commandersaki 14 hours ago
      I didn't find the answer that interesting:

      Vint Cerf: In the early 1970s, while we were developing this, we asked ourselves, should there be patents associated with it? Should there be other constraints? Should it be a licensable thing? The government does license technology that it has paid to develop, but it can also release it openly. And we went through a kind of analysis. Remember that we were thinking this would be a substrate for the American command and control system that would use computers to support command and control. And that we knew that it would have to be interconnected to our allies. So then in 1973, '74, we're saying, well, who are our allies now in 1974? And there's this list. And then we said, well, who were our allies 25 years before that? And it was a different list. And we said, who will our allies be 25 years from now? And we didn't know. So we thought the only way we can be assured that the allies will have access to this is to simply open it up. So we published this openly. All the protocols were made available openly. We encouraged implementations and interoperability. Interoperability. Could I just say one thing about that word, interoperability? Literally, everything in my career has revolved around the ability of disparate and distributed systems to interwork with each other. And interoperability is its own reward. And so I think if there was any theme in my history and in my career, it's been the seeking interoperability among disparate systems

      • lioeters 14 hours ago
        > interoperability is its own reward

        That was one of my favorite points of the interview. He found value in building relationships, improving the space between systems and how they work together. That explains why TCP/IP was not patented - the reasoning was that the protocols needed to adapt to an unknown future when your allies could become enemies, or vice versa, so the best solution was to publish the invention and open it up to everybody.

        "Adversarial interoperability" is a phrase I saw somewhere, and may apply here too.

      • harrouet 13 hours ago
        That was when the US had allies.
  • jibalt 15 hours ago
    I knew Vint when I worked in the UCLA CompSci dept under Steve Crocker. Both were super nice guys. (Jon Postel, the third in the Van Nuys High triumvirate, was far more inscrutable.)
    • ehecatl42 12 hours ago
      I found myself at a dinner table with him during an ACM conference. The fellow's manners are as impeccable as his clothing. The sort of man who irons his own socks... unlike RMS, with whom I also had a one-on-one dinner after bringing him onto campus.

      The only two computing legends I ever personally met.

  • 7e 16 hours ago
    In the early 70s the government owned most DARPA-funded research. So there would have been little point to pursuing a patent.
  • acheron 16 hours ago
    And then he went to work for Google.
    • therealmarv 6 hours ago
      It's worth it to research what he worked on while being at Google.
    • siren2026 14 hours ago
      this is extremely sad.

      That a spyware adtech company is now even able to hire one of the greatest principled brains of our generation. For what it is worth he got hired when most of us still had faith in Google.

      • pak9rabid 3 hours ago
        Could be worse, at least he didn't accidentally end up at Facebook like a certain hero of mine did.
    • paul7986 16 hours ago
      I heard him speak at Google in DC in 2014. It was interesting...
      • wetwater 15 hours ago
        anything in particular ?
  • reacweb 7 hours ago
    [flagged]