Why YC Series A rounds fell off a cliff

(jaredheyman.medium.com)

70 points | by redm 2 days ago

15 comments

  • ohazi 2 hours ago
    > At Rebel, we score every YC startup and founder across hundreds of dimensions using our proprietary Rebel Theorem 5.0 ML/AI model, looking at everything from founder education and work backgrounds, personality traits, archetypes, entrepreneurial track record, founder-product fit, and more.

    Gross.

    • kylecazar 2 hours ago
      The whole idea behind the fund seems incredibly lazy.

      But the name "Rebel Theorem 5.0 ML/AI model" makes me suspect they are full of shit.

      • RGamma 2 hours ago
        Let's face it: It's Claude.
        • lokar 32 minutes ago
          With a highly innovative proprietary prompt.
    • lispisok 57 minutes ago
      Isnt the point of entrepreneurship to blaze your own trail? Seems like machine learning algorithm trained on past entrepreneurs would inherently fail at identifying new ones.
    • bretpiatt 2 hours ago
      How would you prefer investment decisions to be made? Looks like there's a market for quant analysis where LPs respect what they're doing and companies are good to have them as investors.

      We do stuff differently at Redbud Trail Group in alignment with what our LPs are looking for. VCs are just like any other two sided marketplace business trying to build a differentiated offering to both founders and LPs.

      • rkagerer 1 hour ago
        How would you prefer investment decisions to be made?

        Genuinely. Face to face. Without prejudice from a process that industrializes risk assessment and skips over nuance of the individual situation.

        I guess that's the tradeoff if you're trying to scale this field, and why I'd prefer dealing with my investor or investee one on one. Even if it means that investment is delivered at a more incremental pace. Trust is a personal connection, forged over time.

      • HWR_14 1 hour ago
        It's hard for me to imagine decisions at that early a stage can be extensively data driven.
      • jimbokun 1 hour ago
        > How would you prefer investment decisions to be made?

        The YC pitch and interviews seem like a pretty good system.

      • runarberg 2 hours ago
        My go to model would be for founders going to their local credit union and asking for a loan. The loan would be granted if the credit union members see that this thing brings any value for their local community.

        VC funding has done too much damage, and it will continue to do damage no matter the method investors use to evaluate potential investments. I propose we give VC investments a break, say for one or two hundred years, at least.

      • rl3 2 hours ago
        >How would you prefer investment decisions to be made?

        Well, there's this thing in between everyone's ears that can make decisions based on what you might call intuition or the human factor.

        Of course, to each their own. I personally wouldn't take money from someone who's only funding me because their algorithm says I passed its quantitative analysis.

        • gavmor 1 hour ago
          That "only" is doing a lot of work... we don't know the extent of their full process.
      • kevin_thibedeau 1 hour ago
        This rewards PT Barnum types who are better at hyping themselves.
    • rimeice 2 hours ago
      I don’t understand pre series a investors that do this. If you need an algorithm to tell you a founder is good or not you are in precisely the wrong job.
      • guywithahat 1 hour ago
        I mean that sounds like the moneyball argument, saying an algorithm can't know more than the years of experience a scout carries with them. And then, surprise, the algorithm knew way more.

        I would think some kind of unbiased AI would be better at picking out future successful founders than a VC, who could be much more easily mislead

        • bartread 1 hour ago
          > unbiased AI

          And therein lies the root of the problem: it’s not unbiased.

          AI systems have been shown over and over again to contain bias that reflects the biases in their training data.

          And I’d bet it will favour some predictable combination of privileged background, Ivy League, yadda yadda yadda because those are the people life presents with the right opportunities at the right time.

          But there will be huge numbers of other people that won’t be given the opportunity to succeed because the model will be blind to them, and that’s because the current system, from which the training data would be derived, is blind to them.

          So, yeah: gross.

    • close04 2 hours ago
      They say they score the startups and founders but the startup or the product itself maybe fit under “and more”. They rate how determined the founders are to make money at any cost, not the startup, the idea, or the product.
    • sl0wbrainRot 2 hours ago
      Yeah this feels like Halo Effect applied to a spec sheet based on common founder attributes

      Goodhart's law needs to come for VC/startup funds

      It's 100% lazy "Excel sheet driven" decision making, not a good measure for quality relative to ground truth

    • nylonstrung 1 hour ago
      There's no ML model capable of reliably producing usable predictions from such high cardinality qualitative data so this is almost certainly just an LLM prompt + data scraped from LinkedIn or Pitchbook.

      Even if we pretend it isn't just copywriting to scam LPs, the entire idea is that smart VC bets on founders should be made on the most public, surface level information rather than the subtle tells and cues that come up from diligence and interactions with founders.

      In other words, the thesis is to just make decisions like a first year sourcing analyst rather than an experienced, talented Partner.

    • pavel_lishin 1 hour ago
      Not brainpan diameter, birth sign, or favorite Power Ranger?
    • gradus_ad 2 hours ago
      Let's run it on the Rebel founder and team.
    • benatkin 1 hour ago
      Weird that they'd be looking for a founder like Brian Armstrong or a team like Collision Brothers.

      Actually, not weird.

  • surround 1 hour ago
    If you don't want to read the whole article here's the answer to the title:

    "The sudden slowdown in YC startup Series A rates coincides with interest rates climbing through 2022 and 2023."

  • mikert89 2 hours ago
    The bar for series A was frequently just, do they have a product, is it growing, did they go to Harvard or Stanford.

    People have no clue what a free for all the funding markets were. Fortunes were made by people who didn’t even understand their own tech

    • ignoramous 2 hours ago
      > Fortunes were made by people who didn't even understand their own tech

      To be fair, do Larry and Sergey "understand" all of the tech that power myriad of Google's products & infrastructure? Often, folks in charge of rapidly growing businesses (innovations with disruptive potential / products with deep moats / upstarts riding hype cycles / moonshots on verge of breakthroughs) need to be also good at allocating the capital made available to them, including hiring prolific talent required by their respective ventures.

      • serhei 1 hour ago
        Worth looking at Jeff Dean's "Software Systems at Google" talk (2010) to understand what the tech at Google looked like before/after getting serious about scaling and maintainability.
  • mandevil 1 hour ago
    I wonder how much the Section 174 changes to the tax laws that made software development less tax-advantaged contributed to this slow-down?

    The 1st Trump Administration's big tax cut bill changed the tax laws for 2021 and on on how software development could be deducted, and in 2023 the IRS issued guidance for how to do that that made software engineering about 80% worse in terms of tax rates. The 2nd Trump Administration's big tax cut bill returned it to the old methods of deduction in 2025. So this bad tax situation for software development was in effect from 2022-2023 to 2025, which also lines up with the slow-down in funding.

  • makmanalp 2 hours ago
    Will all of what's going on, is there much reason for the average startup to take VC funding anymore?
    • UK-Al05 1 hour ago
      More reason. With Dev skill becoming less important, the main advantage is the amount of capital you can deploy.
      • makmanalp 1 hour ago
        The way I see it, moats are disappearing, and so pumping in more money to juice growth is not what it used to be - it’s not nearly as durable when nowadays people can switch on a dime, and the moment borrowing became a bit expensive, zillion dollar funding rounds started going away. So why give a chunk of a company to someone else?
    • edoceo 2 hours ago
      There are so many funding options and average is hard to quantify here. But, if you really want the Unicorn path YC is one of the key Brands. If you want to build to something moderate (<100M ARR) then I think try one of the dozens of others. And even smaller plays can look at Angels, who've been writing more (smaller) checks.
    • afavour 2 hours ago
      What would have made that change? AI maybe means hiring fewer developers but you’ve still got plenty of other costs. And AI costs.
  • JohnMakin 3 hours ago
    TLDR; interest rates
    • rconti 3 hours ago
      ha, came her to post just that, down to every single character.
      • pocksuppet 28 minutes ago
        Even the semicolon instead of a colon?
    • gadders 3 hours ago
      Innit. End of ZIRP. I'm sure the companies are just as good.
      • bix6 2 hours ago
        Are they? The batches are huge, trample all over each other, sell to each other, and honestly don’t seem as compelling to me personally.
  • dbt00 3 hours ago
    That's a lot of words and a lot of flogging of proprietary scoring models to say "YC is a ZIRP"
  • jdpigeon 3 hours ago
    "We often detect things that happen well in advance of other people."

    "So here's this thing that happened 5 years ago."

  • asdfman123 2 hours ago
    In tech twitter there's a long running joke to explain frivolous things that occurred during the 2010s: "<insert subject here> was a low interest rate phenomenon."
  • rimeice 2 hours ago
    > For this analysis, we used the same data to predict overall Series A rates by batch, and compared that to actual graduation rates.

    Predicted series a rates by batch is a straight horizontal line. Truly groundbreaking.

  • jgalt212 1 hour ago
    Is Heyman's 10% better than others' 10%?
  • DonHopkins 1 hour ago
    Well the fact that YC falls hook line and sinker for the pitches from unethical exploitive sociopathic companies like Standout is certainly a strong argument for YC not being what it used to be. Any sane ethical investor would head for the hills after seeing a demo video like theirs, let alone discovering how Standout demanded job applicants to give them access to their LinkedIn accounts, then spammed their contacts with ai growth hacking slop in their names, without their knowledge, then not even hiring them or paying them for tarnishing their reputation.

    Interviewed at a YC startup, spent 30 hours working on real client roles, and found out 3 weeks later they were using my LinkedIn without permission:

    https://www.reddit.com/r/recruitinghell/comments/1xyr6ml/int...

    https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50542135

    Even before fraudulently exploiting the LinkedIn accounts of their job applicants, their ridiculous promotional video should have been enough evidence that they were not serious people -- missing this hard evidence points to a spectacular failure of due dilligence on YC's part:

    Standout — Hiring is broken. We're fixing it

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7LdjJO-ibdI

    https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50544185

    There is no universe in which fraudulent companies like Standout deserve to be taken seriously and invested in, and in which investors who take them seriously and invest in them have any credibility. After what Standout did, if they're not kicked out of YC, there's something deeply wrong with YC, which does itself severe reputational damage by not policing and punishing this kind of bullshit by their startups. YC should cooperate with the police and lawyers in criminal prosecution and civil lawsuits against companies like Standout, not continue to support them with money and networking and reputation.

    • pocksuppet 4 minutes ago
      Why should YC, which is a company about profiting from investment, care about anything except the amount of profit they will make from their investment? Sociopathic companies make more profit, ergo they should receive more investment.
  • ls-a 2 hours ago
    [dead]