Show HN: Radiotherapy Delivery Demo

(tps.neuralrad.com)

19 points | by coolwulf 6 days ago

6 comments

  • EwanG 10 hours ago
    Probably everything is on such an old stack due to the regulatory pipeline of getting the software approved. I suspect that if this stack is as major a change as the authors suggest, that it will be at least five years before it could be used given the impact of getting something wrong - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Therac-25
    • coolwulf 7 hours ago
      Although FDA regulations are important, for in-house software inside the clinics, we could use them with the approval of IRB (internal review board). A lot of software developed in the clinics are actually being used for treating patients.
  • jagged-chisel 9 hours ago
    Seems to me we can continue to use the known-reliable tech stack, but put a nicer UI on it for explaining the treatment planning process, for simulations, etc.

    Now, explain why you'd need GPU-accelerated dose calculation.

    • coolwulf 9 hours ago
      Dose Cal needs to use Monte Carlo for millions of particles for accurate dose Cal. Without GPU acceleration it would be too slow in practice.
      • jagged-chisel 2 hours ago
        Is this a treatment that is currently in use? If so, how does it work now?
        • coolwulf 2 hours ago
          The one showing at default is not a real patient, it's a human phantom. You can load a real CT image with its RT Plan to see the real patient treatment data.
          • jagged-chisel 1 hour ago
            I’m not asking about your web page. I’m asking if this procedure is currently in use on patients and how that process currently works. I see no need to change the stack behind an approved treatment, and you haven’t made a case for moving it to the GPU.

            If this treatment is not available to patients in the real world because realtime planning is required but the compute is unavailable, then maybe you have a point.

            • coolwulf 42 minutes ago
              Currently treatment planning software needs to run on a dedicated desktop computer running propriatery software. They are also running on GPU to speed up Monte Carlo simulations with millions of particles. Running inside browser with WebGPU would make this technology more easily available for all physicians/Physicists/Dosimetrists/Therapists involved.
  • makmanalp 7 hours ago
    I don't have anything helpful to add other than saying thanks for working on something that matters.
    • coolwulf 7 hours ago
      Thank you for the kind words!